African Commission on
Human and Peoples’ Rights
STATE REPORTING GUIDELINES AND
PRINCIPLES ON ARTICLES 21 AND 24 OF THE
AFRICAN CHARTER RELATING TO
EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES, HUMAN RIGHTS AND
THE ENVIRONMENT
Table of Contents
Foreword by Commissioner Solomon A. Dersso,
Chairperson of the Working Group on Extractive Industries,
Human Rights and Environment in Africa
iv - viii
•
State Reporting Guidelines on Articles 21 and 24 of the
African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights
Relating to the Operations of Extractive Industries
10 - 18
•
Explanatory Note to the State Reporting Guidelines on the
Contents of the Rights and Obligations under Articles 21 and 24
of the African Charter
19 - 40
•
Endnotes
41 - 43
•
Annexes
Resolution 364: Resolution 364: Resolution on Developing Reporting
Guidelines with Respect to the Extractive Industries
ACHPR/Res. 364(LIX) 2016
44
Resolution 367: Resolution on the Niamey Declaration on Ensuring the
Upholding of the African Charter in the Extractive Industries Sector
ACHPR/Res. 367 (LX) 2017
45 - 48
•
Foreword by Commissioner Solomon A. Dersso,
Chairperson of the Working Group on Extractive
Industries, Human Rights and Environment in Africa
I.
Introduction
The extractive industry is a sector that has come to play an increasingly
significant role in the economies of a growing number of African countries.
Despite its potential and, at times, actual contribution to improved living
conditions of citizens, the extractive industries in many parts of the continent
is fraught with major issues impacting on the environment and on the wellbeing
of people living in their areas of operation. The lack of, or weak national
regulatory regimes governing the role of the industry on the continent, as
well as the sector’s inadequate observance of human and peoples’ rights and
environmental and transparency standards have meant that the operations of
extractive industries often result in various human and peoples’ rights issues.
These human rights abuses include dispossession of land and accompanying
displacement of people in the areas of new discoveries of gas, oil and minerals,
weak or poorly beneficial terms of concession, environmental degradation
affecting the livelihood and health of people living adjacent to these areas,
violation of labour rights, lack of transparency about and egregious abuse by
national actors of revenues received from the extractive industries and evasion
of taxes.1 Similarly, as experiences from various parts of the continent show, the
extractive industry has contributed to or otherwise prolonged or exacerbated
internal armed conflicts.2
While there have been reports of serious human rights abuses and violations
in the extractive industries in many parts of Africa where they operate,
a comprehensive and systematic continental framework for monitoring,
reporting on and availing redress for such abuses has yet to be fully developed.
At the same time, the human rights concerns are set to increase as the industry
continues to grow and countries on the continent seek to use the potential
of the extractive industries as a major driver of development. This actual and
potential expansion of the sector adds further impetus to the existing need to
put in place the requisite mechanisms for addressing the plethora of human and
peoples’ rights issues arising from the operations of the extractive industries
in Africa.
iv
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
The need for relevant tools in this regard is twofold. On the one hand the
African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the African Commission)
has to formulate appropriate tools for promoting national standards and
processes that guarantee compliance with human rights and environmental
standards and ensure that the extractive industries meaningfully contribute
to the improvement of the living standards of people. On the other hand,
the African Commission should also have at its disposal relevant tools and
mechanisms for monitoring and addressing abuses of human and peoples’
rights as a result of the extractive industries.
The issues that arise from the operations of the extractive industries concern
various civil and political as well as socio-economic rights guaranteed under
the African Charter. Unlike other international human rights instruments, the
African Charter additionally guarantees peoples’ rights. Articles 21 and 24
of the African Charter are the relevant parts of the Charter that specifically
concern the extractive industries. Article 21 guarantees the right of all peoples
to freely dispose of their wealth and natural resources. Article 24 provides for
the right of all peoples to a general satisfactory environment, favourable to
their development. These rights of peoples are at the core of the concerns
surrounding the protection of rights relating to the operations of the extractive
industries in Africa.
Over the years, the African Commission has been called upon to deal with
cases of abuses and violations of human and peoples’ rights taking place
in the context of the extractive industries. Recognizing the gravity of the
adverse human and peoples’ rights impacts of the operations of the extractive
industries in various parts of the continent and the need for addressing them,
in 2009 the African Commission established the Working Group on Extractive
Industries, the Environment and Human Rights. Within this framework of
having a mechanism focusing on this area and as part of the implementation
of the Commission’s responsibilities of reviewing the reports of States under
Article 62 of the African Charter, the African Commission has developed the
practice of formulating questions on extractive industries and the environment
in the context of the reporting obligations of States on Articles 21 and 24 of
the African Charter.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
v
The State Reporting process under Article 62 of the African Charter is one of
the most useful mechanisms through which the African Commission monitors
the implementation of the rights guaranteed in the African Charter and clarifies
what is expected of States under the African Charter. Additionally, while it
enables States Parties to the African Charter to introspect and assess their
performance vis-à-vis the obligations they have undertaken under the African
Charter, it also offers the platform for constructive dialogue on existing and
emerging issues affecting the rights guaranteed in the Charter and on how these
issues can be addressed. Its effectiveness depends, among others, on the quality
of the reporting guidelines and the nature of information that States provide
in their reports.
In the course of reviewing state reports in terms of Article 62 of the Charter, a
number of issues have been observed. In the first place, while progress has been
made in reviewing and monitoring human rights issues relating to both civil and
political rights and to a lesser but increasing extent, socio-economic rights, very
little, if any, progress has been made in reviewing and monitoring rights issues
relating to peoples’ rights. Assessment of reports submitted by State Parties
to the African Charter shows that usually no adequate or relevant information
is provided on legislative and other measures taken for the operationalization
of peoples’ rights under the Charter, including those under Articles 21, and 24
of the Charter. Additionally, there is no consistent and standardized approach
in the provision of relevant information on measures that reporting States
have taken towards the promotion and protection of Articles 21 and 24 of
the African Charter. State Reports often provide inadequate, irrelevant and/
or no information on issues encountered and their experiences in ensuring
observance of the Charter rights in the context of extractive industries.
The State Reporting Guidelines of the Commission, adopted in 1998, provide
little detail with respect to Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter. The 1998
Guidelines lack specific reporting guidelines that would enable State Parties to
avail the relevant information on the regulatory framework governing extractive
industries, issues of human rights in the extractive industries and measures to
be taken to address the issues. The guidelines provide no or little guidance on
the content of the rights under Articles 21 and 24 and how State Parties should
give effect to those rights to ensure that the operation of extractive industries
is in accord with the African Charter. This inadequacy of the existing State
Reporting Guidelines means that the provision of effective guidelines becomes
vi
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
an area where the African Commission’s human and peoples’ rights promotion
and protection system needs strengthening.
As part of this effort to strengthen its monitoring role, the African Commission
took a decision through its Resolution on Developing Reporting Guidelines with
Respect to the Extractive Industries ACHPR/Res. 364(LIX) 2016, mandating
the Working Group to elaborate State Periodic Reporting Guidelines on Articles
21 and 24 of the African Charter. This document starts by setting out the
context and scope of the Guidelines, followed by the Guidelines themselves,
which provide the details of the issues on which states are expected to report in
demonstrating their compliance with Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter.
Because these provisions have received so little attention in the past, there was
also a need to further elaborate on the content of the obligations under Articles
21 and 24 the African Charter in the context of the extractive industries. To
this end, the Guidelines accompanied by an explanatory note on the contents
of Articles 21 and 24, providing further reference on the legal basis of and
background to the Guidelines.
II.
Context and scope
The principal audience that these reporting guidelines target are the State
Parties to the African Charter concerning the preparation of the sections of
their State Reports that relate to Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter. The
reporting guidelines as well as the explanatory note that accompanies it also aim
at facilitating the work of other stakeholders, including non-state actors and
particularly civil society organizations in their participation in and contribution
to the preparation of State Reports as they relate to Articles 21 and 24 of the
Charter. It also aids the African Commission in the consideration and review
of Periodic State Reports, particularly as they relate to the themes covered here.
The Reporting Guidelines identify the issues under Articles 21 and 24 of
the African Charter on which States Parties should provide information
in their Periodic Reports to the African Commission generally and with
specific reference to the operations of extractive industries in their territories
in particular. As part of and in order to identify the full scope of the issues
that should be covered under Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter, the
Reporting Guidelines are accompanied by an explanatory note that elaborate
the principles underlying these rights; substantive contents of the rights; and
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
vii
the obligations arising from these rights in respect of both the State and the
companies involved in extractive industries.
III.
Process followed in adoption of the Guidelines
Following the adoption of Resolution 364 on Developing Reporting Guidelines
with Respect to the Extractive Industries during the Commission’s 59th
Ordinary Session, I convened a technical expert meeting on the elaboration of
the draft guidelines on 2 to 3 December 2016 in Dakar, Senegal, in my capacity
as Chairperson of the Working Group on Extractive Industries. This meeting
laid down the parameters and set in motion the process for the drafting of the
state reporting guidelines and principles relating to Articles 21 and 24 of the
African Charter. Following development of the draft guidelines and principles,
a second technical expert consultation was held on 14 to 15 September 2017 in
Dakar. This provided an opportunity for reviewing, updating and validating the
initial draft on state reporting guidelines and the principles relating to Articles
21 and 24 of the African Charter.
This expert validated draft was thereafter presented for a stakeholder consultation
during a panel discussion at the 61st Ordinary Session of the Commission in
November 2017 and was also placed on the website of the Commission for
further input from stakeholders who were not able to attend the Session. The
final guidelines and principles were adopted by the Commission at its 62nd
Ordinary Session in May 2018.
Finally, I wish to acknowledge with appreciation the support of the Organisation
internationale de la Francophonie for the printing of this document.
Solomon Ayele Dersso
Chairperson of the WGEI
viii
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
State Reporting Guidelines on Articles 21 and 24 of the
African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights Relating
to the Operations of Extractive Industries
I.
Applicable Articles of the African Charter
Article 21
1. All peoples shall freely dispose of their wealth and natural resources.
This right shall be exercised in the exclusive interest of the people.
In no case shall a people be deprived of it.
2. In case of spoliation the dispossessed people shall have the right
to the lawful recovery of its property as well as to an adequate
compensation.
3. The free disposal of wealth and natural resources shall be exercised
without prejudice to the obligation of promoting international
economic cooperation based on mutual respect, equitable exchange
and the principles of international law.
4. States parties to the present Charter shall individually and collectively
exercise the right to free disposal of their wealth and natural resources
with a view to strengthening African unity and solidarity.
5. States parties to the present Charter shall undertake to eliminate all
forms of foreign economic exploitation particularly that practiced
by international monopolies so as to enable their peoples to fully
benefit from the advantages derived from their national resources.
Article 24
All peoples shall have the right to a general satisfactory environment
favourable to their development.
1.
10
II.
Definitions
The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (African
Commission) finds that the elaboration of the Guidelines requires the
provision of the definitions of key terms.
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
2. For purposes of these Guidelines, ‘artisanal or small-scale mining’
refers to mining practised by individuals, groups or communities, with low
technology, and often informally or outside of the regulations which apply
to commercial scale mining.3
3. ‘Environment’ as used in Article 24 of the African Charter refers to the
natural surroundings including the soil, the flora and fauna, the air and
water bodies as well as the living species in such water bodies on which
people depend not only for their survival but also for the sustenance and
improvement of their wellbeing.4
4. For purposes of these Guidelines the term ‘extractive industries’ refers
broadly to the operations by private or State actors, usually at a commercial
scale, of mining or extraction of natural resources for economic gain. In
the narrow sense it refers to oil, gas and other mining industries and the
activities involved in these industries.5 The scope of the term ‘extractive
industries’ is accordingly the activities of the companies or enterprises
through which non-renewable resources such as oil, metals, coal, stone and
gas are obtained from under the ground, however, to the extent that it is
applicable, it also includes other exploitation of resources, such as industrial
logging and massive agricultural undertakings for the production of biofuel.6
5. ‘Exploitation’ in this context refers to all activities that enable actors and
stakeholders to engage in business in first, secondary and tertiary sectors in
relation to the natural resources and other forms of wealth, and includes
extraction, production, commercialization and exports of natural resources.7.
6. For purposes of these Guidelines, apart from its reference to the entire
population of a State,8 the term ‘peoples’ under Articles 21 and 24 of the
African Charter refers to a group of individuals having a common identity
on account of objective markers of shared language, racial or ethnic makeup,
historical experience, religious, cultural or ideological affinity, connection to
a particular territory and the subjective manifestations of self-identification
and awareness as a distinct group possessing of shared identity.9 Peoples are
therefore not to be equated solely with ‘Nation’ or ‘State’, but include subnational groups including communities of a particular region exhibiting the
above characteristics, or people whose resources are exploited under foreign
occupation.10 Local communities or individuals who are most immediately
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
11
affected by activities of extractive industries can claim the rights guaranteed
in these articles to ‘peoples’. ‘Communities’ in this context refers to residents
of a locality which is organized either as part of an administrative or selfgoverning unit of a state or on the basis of the customary or religious law/s
of the area.
7. ‘Wealth’ as used in Article 21 of the African Charter refer to a people’s
tangible and intangible possessions having socio-economic value, including
natural resources; and ‘natural resources’ as used in Article 21 refer to both
the non-renewable resources including oil, gas and minerals and renewable
resources, tangible and intangible, including the sun, soil, water, wind, fauna
and flora.11 Natural resources thus encompass all assets or materials that
constitute the natural capital of a nation.
III.
Guidelines for State Reporting under Article 21 and 24
In terms of Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter, the periodic report
that States submit under Article 62 should include information on the issues
highlighted below. In preparing the Report, States are encouraged to ensure
that their Ministries of Justice, Finance, Trade and Investment, Environment,
Mining, their Revenue Collection Authorities, Reserve Banks and Auditors
General are involved.
In relation to Article 21, the state report should include the
following information:
12
Background
a) The types of natural resources which are exploited or available
within the territory of the State;
b) The activities being undertaken by extractive industries within the
territories of the State;
c) The list of the transnational or multinational companies and
subsidiaries as well as local enterprises involved in these activities,
as well as the extent of their involvement;
d) Information on the size and lifestyle of the populations or
communities living in the territories where extractive industries are
undertaken;
e) Information on how the rights under Articles 21 are given
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
recognition in the national laws of the country including guarantees
for judicial enforcement;
f) Information on the government body responsible for natural
resources development and the scope of its legal authority and
responsibility;
Land use and ownership
g) Legal guarantees to people, and women in particular, to live on,
access, develop and use the land, vegetation, water sources and
the aquatic resources on which they depend for their survival and
livelihoods as per Article 21(1);
h) Legal frameworks providing guarantees of ownership over land and
natural resources to people, including women, in territories affected
by extractive activities, as well as relevant redress mechanisms for
expropriation, resettlement or other interference with use of the
land and lawful recovery of property and adequate compensation
as required by article 21(2) of the Charter;
i) Information on the legal and procedural safeguards to protect
people from arbitrary and forcible expropriation of land;
j) Information on the standards that apply in cases of expropriation
of land for ensuring priori consultation, prompt and effective
compensation and resettlement support;
k) The legal and institutional safeguards available to protect the
people from foreign economic exploitation including through
restricting percentage of foreign ownership and to ensure that the
people meaningfully benefit from the operations of multinational
companies engaged in extractive industries as per Article 21(5);
l) The legal framework for sustainable development as it relates to
natural resources and the extent to which it makes the realization of
human rights a prerequisite for sustainability;
Participation and consultation
m) Information on legislation regulating local participation, including the
extent of compliance with the substantive and procedural guarantees
of Article 21, including prior consultation and substantive and rigorous
participation of affected people in decision-making processes;
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
13
n) Legislative provisions which ensure equal representation of women
in legislative and decision-making fora and consultations;
o) Information on the applicable procedures for granting of
concessions or licenses for exploration and extraction of resources,
including consultation with and participation of all affected people
in decision-making, prior to and during environmental, human
rights and social impact assessments;
p) Information on legal requirements that ensure to have access to
information on all aspects of exploration and extraction plans
including the findings of such assessments ahead of the finalization
of such plans;
q) Availability of established mechanisms or approaches for
incorporating and addressing the concerns of affected people
including the possibility of challenging the decisions in court;
r) Provision of legal guarantees that enable and support selforganization of affected people for their effective participation
including through traditional governance bodies and the advocacy
and capacity development support of community based and civilsociety organizations;
14
Human rights compliance in relation to large- and small-scale extractive
industries
s) The availability of transparency, environmental, and labour
standards that ensure that companies engaged in the extractive
industries operate in compliance with human rights standards;
t) Provision of data showing measures taken by the State to enforce
compliance with these standards;
u) Requirements for and availability of technically equipped and wellresourced regulatory bodies mandated to undertaking monitoring
and reviewing of the compliance of the extractive industries with
their obligations under the licensing agreement and the governing
legal standards particularly those relating to transparency (anticorruption), labour and fiscal (tax) responsibilities of companies;
v) Legislation ensuring strict regulation of the use by extractive
companies of private security companies which interfere with the
responsibilities of national and local security forces and create
tension with host communities;
w) Provisions for regulation, monitoring and providing support for
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
persons engaged in artisanal and small-scale mining in applying
minimum environmental, health and safety standards, as well as
steps taken to formalize the sector;
Grievance mechanisms
x) Provisions laying down administrative, civil and criminal liability
for violations of applicable human rights, responsibility on fiscal
obligations and transparency and other national legal obligations;
y) The judicial and non-judicial complaints mechanisms including
the extent to which they are equipped and resourced to adjudicate
grievances of affected communities or individuals;
z) Provide data on complaints received and settled through such
mechanisms, including statistics on the number of individuals
using the grievance mechanisms; on the number of companies
found responsible for violations; and on the applicable sanctions
or penalties that have been imposed including revoking of licenses;
aa) Provision of legal aid and other measures that enable persons and
affected communities to access grievance mechanisms;
Fiscal regulation
ab) General financial information, including the percentage of the
GDP received from the extractive industry;
ac) Information on the relationship payments made to market value of
prices paid by extractive industries for resources in raw form and
refined form;
ad) Detailed information on any financial or tax incentives provided to
companies in the extractive industries;
ae) Steps taken to address illicit financial flow through amendments to
national tax laws and policies, rules on related party transactions,
company laws and policies, banking laws and policies and laws and
policies governing the financial services sector;
af) Measures put in place to renegotiate agreements that limit the
State’s ability to collect adequate revenue from commercial activities
within the extractives sector;
ag) Information on the legislative, administrative and judicial measures
put in place to combat corruption in the extractive industries sector;
ah) Information on the extent to which the State is involved in jointventures and the tax implications of such ventures;
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
15
ai) Legislative and regulatory provisions on requirements for reporting
to legislative and local council bodies and the public on the profits
of extractive industries, the revenues that the authorities collected
from extractive industries;
aj) Information on the mechanisms put in place for the judicious and
transparent administration of the revenues collected;
ak) Information on reporting to parliament and the public on how the
revenues received are being managed and utilized;
al) Establishment of standards that guarantee reasonable revenue
sharing arrangement between national government and local
authorities in the affected areas, to ensure that the people meaningfully
benefit from the operations of multinational companies engaged in
extractive industries, and to cooperate with other State Parties in
eliminating foreign economic exploitation.
In relation to Article 24 the state report should include the
following information:
Background
a) Information on how the rights under Article 24 of the African
Charter are given recognition in the laws of the country as required
under Article 1 of the Charter
b) Information on guarantees for judicial enforcement of the right to
environment as per Article 1 of the African Charter which requires
giving effect to the rights in the Charter;
c) The applicable laws and regulations, including administrative laws,
on the protection of the environment, as well as the nature of
environmental issues that the applicable legal regime covers;
d) The institutions and regulatory bodies responsible for inspection,
monitoring and enforcement of environmental laws, as well as their
competencies;
Implementation
e) The mechanisms put in place for undertaking or overseeing the
conducting of internationally accepted environmental risk assessment
prior to implementation of industrial scale economic projects;
16
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
f) Information on the details on the steps and standards that should
be followed in undertaking environmental impact assessment;
g) Legal provisions on the requirement for instituting appropriate
measures for mitigating identified risks arising from the
environmental and social impact assessments;
h) Provisions for monitoring the environment to ensure the
conservation and improvement of the environment;
i) Information on the measures put in place for protecting people from
environmental degradation and pollution including the ecologically
sustainable use of natural resources and environmentally compatible
waste disposal system tailored to various industries;
j) Information on legal and policy provisions on steps to be followed
for the rehabilitation of threatened environment;
k) The steps to be taken and the roles that responsible actors (state and
private actors responsible) bear for responding to and addressing
the despoliation or pollution of the environment through
scientific inspection of the environmental and social impacts
of environmental pollution or despoliation and implementing
measures fit for rehabilitation of the polluted land or water body;
l) Information on legal guarantees for providing effective compensation
for those affected by the despoliation of the environment;
Consultation and participation
m) The avenues available for effective and inclusive public consultation
and meaningful participation of affected people in the protection
and conservation of the environment;
n) Provisions guaranteeing the participation of affected communities
in environmental and social impact assessment processes,
o) Provisions legally requiring national and local authorities to provide
full and accessible information about proposed and ongoing
projects to people in affected people including on the potential
impact of such projects;
p) Provision establishing avenues for people to make oral or written
submissions individually or collectively including through civil
society organizations and ensuring that their concerns are properly
taken onboard.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
17
Sanctions and grievance mechanisms
q) Applicable administrative, civil and criminal liabilities for breaches
of environmental standards;
r) Locally accessible and effective judicial and non-judicial dispute
settlement and complaints adjudication mechanisms for addressing
legal disputes over the protection of the environment;
s) Provide data on complaints received and settled through such
mechanisms, including statistics on the number of individuals
using the grievance mechanisms; on the number of companies
found responsible for violations; and on the applicable sanctions
or penalties that have been imposed including revoking of licenses;
t) Provision of legal aid and other measures that enable persons and
affected communities to access grievance mechanisms.
18
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
Explanatory Note to the State Reporting Guidelines on
the Contents of the Rights and Obligations under
Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter
I
Underlying Principles
1. Indivisibility and interdependence – These are underlying principles of
the rights to wealth and natural resources and environment.12 The rights
guaranteed under Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter are indivisible
from and interdependent with the civil and political rights and economic,
social and cultural rights as well as other peoples’ rights enshrined in the
African Charter.13 The implementation and the full realization of the rights
under these articles depend on and have to be pursued with due regard, as
necessary, to all other rights and the duties of persons as provided for in the
African Charter.14
2. As outlined by the African Commission in Social and Economic Rights Action
Center (SERAC) and Center for Economic and Social Rights (CESR) v. Nigeria
(SERAC case), addressing the rights issues arising from the operations of
extractive industries notably those involving Articles 21 and 24 of the Charter
requires the use of ‘the diverse rights contained in the African Charter’.
In this case, the Commission affirmed that the protection of the rights in
Articles 21 and 24 requires an integrated and complementary reading and
application of civil and political rights (Articles 2 and 4) and economic, social
and cultural rights (Articles 14, 16 and 18). The interdependence of rights
also means that the use of natural resources, including when undertaken
in the pursuit of national development endeavors, has to be done in an
environmentally sustainable way and with due respect to all the civil and
political, socio-economic and peoples’ rights of the African Charter.
3. The principle of solidarity - The rights guaranteed under Articles 21
and 24 are also underpinned by the principles of solidarity and the shared
interests of individuals, communities and the peoples’ of a State as a whole.
The State has, in accordance with the principle of State sovereignty over
natural resources, the main responsibility for ensuring natural resources
stewardship with, and for the interest of, the population.15 Although natural
resources under Article 21 are often localized in a particular region, this
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
19
does not mean that entitlement to the benefits from the sustainable and
human rights compliant use of such natural resources is limited to affected
people living on or near such territory - the peoples of the State as a whole
are also entitled to benefit from such resources16 with full respect to the
interests specific to the communities living on or near such territory. The
protection and preservation of a ‘generally satisfactory environment’ under
Article 24 as a shared property entails that all individuals, communities and
legal entities, most notably industrial enterprises such as companies involved
in extractive industries, have the duty for the protection and preservation of
the environment. 17
4. The principle of using wealth and natural resources in the exclusive
interest of the people - Underlying the right of peoples to freely dispose
of their wealth and natural resources is the principle that the use of natural
resources should be for the exclusive interest and benefit of the citizens
of a State in general and host communities in particular. In this regard,
the rights of the people of the State as a whole may not detract from the
specific rights of affected people who are directly impacted by extractive
industries to benefit from the exploitation of natural resources. While this
does not confer an absolute right on affected people over the national
interest, there is a need for these, at time conflicting, interests to be balanced
in a fair and just manner through a cost benefit analysis, which does not
prejudice the affected people. Intertwined with this principle are the related
principles of transparency and accountability pertaining to the exploration
and development of natural resources, particularly where undertaken by
foreign owned companies.
5. Sovereignty and ownership - Another principle underlying the right to
freely dispose of wealth, is the principle of sovereignty and ownership.
According to Article 21(1) of the African Charter, in no case shall a
people be deprived of the right and its exercise shall be in their exclusive
interest. At the very least, as outlined in the SERAC case, this bars the nonparticipation of affected people in the development processes (involving
the use of natural resources) and the exclusion of affected people from
material benefit accruing to them. The principle of sovereignty is also
captured in the provisions of Article 21(5), which require States to eliminate
all forms of foreign economic exploitation, and which thus vests the power
of economic decision-making in the State and the people themselves,
20
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
rather than any outside entities. This also closely relates to the principle
of self-determination and the power to pursue their economic and social
development according to the policy they have freely chosen, as provided
for in Article 20.
6. The principle of effective participation - A further principle underlining
Articles 21 and 24 of the African Charter is participation of affected people
in all decisions relating to the exploration and use of natural resources and
decisions with consequences on the environment. As outlined in the SERAC
case, where people live within the areas of operation of extractive industries
or where decisions with environmental consequences are being taken, such
affected people should be provided with the necessary information.
7. Non-discrimination and equality - The rights under Articles 21 and 24
are also premised on the principles of non-discrimination and equality, rights
guaranteed under Article 2 of the African Charter. Any discrimination on
any of the listed grounds under Article 2 of the Charter in access to or
enjoyment of the rights in these Articles is proscribed. Similarly, the rights
guaranteed in these articles should be applied and operationalized with
particular regard to the most marginalized and socio-economically excluded
members of society, including most notably women, but also children,
persons with disabilities and older persons. In the implementation of these
rights, policy measures should aim at rectifying existing inequalities based
on gender, ethnicity, religion and race and other similar grounds.
II
Content of the rights guaranteed in Articles 21 and 24
8. Article 21 of the African Charter stipulates
1. All peoples shall freely dispose of their wealth and natural resources.
This right shall be exercised in the exclusive interest of the people.
In no case shall a people be deprived of it.
2. In case of spoliation the dispossessed people shall have the right
to the lawful recovery of its property as well as to an adequate
compensation.
3. The free disposal of wealth and natural resources shall be exercised
without prejudice to the obligation of promoting international
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
21
economic co-operation based on mutual respect, equitable exchange
and the principles of international law.
4. State parties to the present Charter shall individually and collectively
exercise the right to free disposal of their wealth and natural
resources with a view to strengthening African unity and solidarity.
5. State parties to the present Charter shall undertake to eliminate all
forms of foreign economic exploitation particularly that practiced
by international monopolies so as to enable their peoples to fully
benefit from the advantages derived from their national resources.
9. First and foremost, the right to freely dispose of wealth and natural
resources is an inviolable right of all peoples (Article 21(1) last sentence), an
extension and central element of the right to self-determination provided
for in Article 20 of the Charter. The right and the entitlements arising from
it belong to peoples. As per the second sentence of Article 21(1) & (4),
States only have a delegated role entailing the exercise of this right. Article
21 is empathic that this role of States has to be executed in the exclusive
interest of the people. The last provision of Article 21(5) explicitly affirms
that peoples of States party to the African Charter are entitled to ‘fully
benefit from the advantages derived from their national resources’.
10. The essence of this right entails that people have secure access to, use of and
benefit from their wealth and natural resources. ‘Peoples’ and individuals are
thus entitled to live on, access, develop and use the land, vegetation, water
sources and the aquatic resources on which they depend for their survival
and livelihoods.18 Integral to the right to property, which is guaranteed under
Article 14 of the Charter, such entitlement to live on, develop or use land
and such other resources does not depend on whether such entitlement
arises from custom and hence historically acquired or the formal laws of
the country.19 This right also entitles peoples and individuals to be provided
with requisite support that enables them to access, develop and use these
resources in a way that is sustainable and improves their standard of living.
11. With respect to natural resources that require industrial scale development,
Article 21 entails that local people and nationals are provided with the
legal guarantee to participate in the prospecting and development of such
resources.20 It also entitles them to acquire a stake in the project for the
22
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
prospecting and developing of such resources. Article 21 also entitles
affected people living in the areas where industrial development of
resources takes place to benefit from the proceeds of the extraction and
sale of such resources. The benefit to be accrued to affected people should
be on the basis of internationally acceptable and legally established schemes
for equitable sharing of revenues from operations of extractive industries
between national government, regional authorities and local affected
people. Furthermore, beneficiation for affected people should extend
beyond revenues alone, and should include other forms of beneficiation,
such as minimum local content requirements in extractive industries and
contribution to local development projects. Not only that the activities
of extractive industries should not lead to make the conditions of life of
people living in the territory worse off (such as through limiting access to or
spoiling the land and water on which they depend for their livelihoods) but
also contribute to the improvement of their standard of life both measured
both objectively and subjectively.
12. The right to share in the benefits derived from the development or sale of
natural resources extends to all peoples of a state.
13. Where local people are engaged in artisanal or small-scale mining, they are
entitled to the protections that should be provided for in the necessary
human rights, safety and environmental regulatory measures. Specifically,
the minimum safety measures required to safeguard the health and life
of artisanal miners should be put in place. Steps should be taken to raise
awareness of artisanal miners regarding their rights and responsibilities, and
support them in building their capacities to safeguard against environmental
damages and health hazards.
14. The protections and entitlements expounded in the foregoing paragraphs
constitute the positive guarantees and substantive elements of Article 21 of
the African Charter. Article 21 additionally provides negative guarantees.
Article 21 (1) particularly guarantees that in no way should any people be
deprived of the protections, entitlements and benefits arising from the right
to dispose of wealth and national resources. Further, Article 21 protects
nationals of a state and local communities against acts or conditions or
arrangements that interfere with or impede their right to the disposal of
wealth and natural resources. Similarly, as outlined in the SERAC case, with
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
23
respect to access to and use of land, fauna and flora, the state should, at the
minimum, ensure that its agents or any third party does not interfere with
the right of communities and individuals to access and use these resources.
Most notably, this protection extends against activities of extractive
industries or other commercial activities that not only impede local peoples’
access to and use of the land, fauna and flora in the territories they live on,
but also contravene other rights of the Africa Charter, such as the right to
the best attainable state of health under Article 16, which may be affected
by activities polluting the air.
15. Another substantive right that gives enforcement to both the positive rights
guarantees and the negative protections that arise from Article 21 (1) is the
right to remedy in case of violations. Understandably, the right to remedy is
inherent in and central to all human rights and is also embedded in the right
to access to justice. Additionally, this right to remedy includes reparations.
Indeed, Article 21(2) stipulates that the reparation in ‘case of spoliation’ for
the ‘dispossessed people’ takes the form of restitution or compensation.
Any dispossession of land shall be on the basis of law and undertaken
solely in the public interest and should be reasonable and proportionate.
Peoples affected by land dispossession should be provided both with full,
effective, fair and adequate compensation and support for rehabilitation.
Such compensation has to be made available prior to the removal of such
peoples from their land and has to be determined in consultation with the
affected people and should not in any way make their living conditions worse
off. Compensation should also take account of the additional vulnerability
of certain groups, such as female-headed households.
16. One qualification to the right of people to freely dispose of their wealth and
natural resources is international cooperation. Most specifically, the exercise
of this right should not prejudice obligations arising from international
cooperation, including those obligations arising from agreements relating
to trans-boundary resources. The most notable implication of this is that
the disposal or extraction of natural resources should have a developmental
purpose and should be environmentally sustainable. The obligations arising
from such international trade or investment agreements and/or bilateral
investment agreements will not be acceptable under Article 21(3) unless
they are based on ‘mutual respect, equitable exchange and principles of
international law’. Additionally, obligations arising from such agreements
24
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
that substantively negate or restrict the essence of the right of peoples to
dispose of their wealth and natural resources shall not be protected under
Article 21(3).
17. It is important to note that the qualification on the right of peoples to
freely dispose of their wealth and natural resources under Article 21(3) is
itself circumscribed under Article 21(5). This latter provision imposes a
pre-emptory obligation on the State to ensure the protection of their people
from all forms of foreign economic exploitation. States should thus prevent
the abuse of natural resources by foreign or international economic actors.
The implication of this is that the terms between a State and extractive
industry investors on financial revenues arising from exploitation of natural
resources should not be much lower than international standards and hence
exploitative. Similarly, the terms on the tax break and duty free privilege
benefits to extractive industries, as well as concessions arising from jointventures, should not be of such a nature that it deprives the people of the
benefits to which they are entitled.
18. Existing bilateral and multilateral agreements between states, or with
international financial institutions, that are not in line with Article 21(5)
should be revised or renegotiated. The negotiation of such agreements
should include the minimum guarantees under Article 21 of the African
Charter including responsibility of international economic actors for the
human and peoples’ rights consequences of their activities and for fully
meeting all fiscal obligations and respecting internationally acceptable labour
and environmental standards. Any clause in such agreements that protects
such entities from liability, or grants them immunity from accountability for
the adverse human and peoples’ rights or environmental consequences of
their activities would be deemed contrary to the guarantees under Article 21
of the African Charter.
19. State parties are also obliged, under Article 21(4) to “individually and
collectively exercise the right to free disposal of their wealth and natural
resources with a view to strengthening African unity and solidarity”. While
this is an obligation imposed on State Parties vis-à-vis other African States,
the benefit of such cooperation would also accrue to the people of the
States, and citizens should thus be able to require that their governments
comply with this provision.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
25
20. In addition to the substantive entitlements provided for in the foregoing
paragraphs, Article 21 also entails procedural guarantees for its effective
realization. The first procedural guarantee is effective and genuine
consultation and substantive and rigorous participation in decision-making
on plans regarding the exploration and extraction of natural resources. This
entails that affected people living in the territories where such exploration
and extraction works are planned are provided with all the information on
all aspects of such plan, including the findings of environmental, human
rights and social impact assessments, ahead of the finalization of the plan.
Such information should be easily accessible, and should be provided at the
conception, as well as throughout the life-span of the project.
21. Effective enjoyment of and access to the entitlements and protections under
Article 21 also require that awareness creation and capacity building support
is provided to affected people. In the context of the operations of extractive
industries, such awareness creation and capacity building support should be
not only about the legal entitlements and protections to which the affected
people are entitled but also the obligations of the extractive industries and
thereby enabling local communities to monitor the operations of extractive
industries.
22. Provision of all the necessary information as negotiations for exploration
and development starts and in an accessible manner as well as substantive
and rigorous participation is particularly peremptory where exploration and
extraction of resources necessitate expropriation of land from affected
people (and hence their resettlement) or such other restriction to resources
that they depend on for their livelihood. People who may be affected
by plans for exploration and extraction activities should in particular be
provided with not only the relevant information in terms of how they may
be affected in the language that they understand but also the opportunity to
participate meaningfully and have their views incorporated in any decision
on the measures to be taken to limit and rectify the impacts. All steps should
also be taken to ensure that the impact of expropriation and resettlement
is minimized. Consultation and participation should take account of all
affected persons, at the local, regional, national and international levels,
where decisions are made about the extractive industry and ensure that their
concerns are fully integrated in decisions.
26
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
23. Fundamental to full and informed participation in decision-making processes,
the right to information, arising from Article 9 of the African Charter, and
rigorous consultation presupposes and is predicated on internationally
acceptable human rights, environmental and social impact assessments. As
the African Commission pointed out in the SERAC case, environmental
impact assessments have to be conducted in compliance with internationally
acceptable standards. Such assessment should involve communities and
individuals in the territory of proposed extractive operations and take
account of local knowledge systems related to the environment. Similarly,
there should be human rights and social impact assessments, which should
be conducted with the free and full participation of prospective affected
people and having regard to indigenous knowledge and information as well
as the needs of vulnerable groups such as children, indigenous peoples,
older persons and migrant workers.
24. The other procedural guarantee relates to the provision of effective
mechanisms for redress or remedy. This entails that judicial and non-judicial
grievance mechanisms are put in place and that such mechanisms are
adequately equipped and resourced for handling cases involving extractive
industries. Such mechanisms should also be accessible to affected people.
Accessibility entails not only physical proximity but also importantly
familiarity and flexibility of the processes to allow affected people to easily
bring their complaints. Effective access to courts also requires that statutes
of limitations or other excessively onerous procedural requirements (such
as production of title deed) should not be used to impose restrictions on
the ability of people to bring complaints where their rights have been
violated. Human rights defenders who speak out and advocate for measures
to ensure the respect of human rights of affected people must be able to
assist affected people without fear of reprisals from the government or the
company involved in extractive industries and the State should ensure that
there is not impunity for threats, attacks and acts of intimidation against
those advocating for the rights of affected communities irrespective of
their designation as human rights defenders, including women human rights
defenders.
25. Additionally, within the framework of Article 21(2), people whose land, water
or source of livelihood have been disrupted or spoiled by dispossession are
entitled to measures for restoration of their property and to full, effective
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
27
and adequate compensation not only for the socio-economic impacts of the
interference including opportunity costs but also to adverse social impacts.
All measures that are necessary for supporting the resettlement and full
rehabilitation of the livelihood of affected people should be put in place.
26. The other right that is also the subject matter of the reporting guidelines
is Article 24. This article states that ‘[a]ll peoples shall have the right to a
general satisfactory environment favourable to their development.’
27. Central to this right is the recognition of the importance of a clean and safe
environment to the quality of life of people. As its terms make clear, what
is guaranteed under Article 24 is not the right to an ideal environment that is
completely unaffected or completely clean. It is rather an environment that
is clean enough for a safe and secure life and development of individuals
and people.
28. With regard to the requirement of being favourable to their development,
this entails that the environment should be used in a sustainable manner,
which fulfills the needs of the present generation, without compromising
the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. In this context
sustainability is understood as encompassing all aspects of their lives and
livelihoods, including identity, culture, religion and other aspects having
regard to plurality of interests and the delicate balance that should be struck.
In terms of specific legal entitlements that this right gives rise to, people are
first and foremost entitled to protection from environmental degradation
and pollution. This would entail that people are protected from activities
having the effect of degrading or spoiling the soil, water, fauna and flora
and the air of the physical environment.
29. Protection from environmental degradation or pollution entails that people
are provided with the space (including the right to form community based
associations) and the necessary support not only to employ ecologically
sustainable use of natural resources for their development but also to
conserve their environment. People are also entitled to the enabling legal and
institutional frameworks and technical provisions for engaging in awareness
creation and capacity development works necessary both to help them
avoid practices inimical to their environment and pursue locally adaptable
methods of conservation and improvement of their environment.
28
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
30. The right to clean environment under Article 24 requires that appropriate
environmental risk assessments be undertaken prior to industrial
development or the initiation of small-scale/artisanal mining. As corollary
to this, it is imperative that the necessary measures for mitigating identified
risks are instituted as part of building industrial plants or setting up the
small-scale operations.
31. Equally, there is a need for putting in place a waste disposal system that
conforms to acceptable standards of environmental safety. Specifically,
the acceptable waste disposal standards appropriate to various sectors or
industries should be legally established and strictly enforced. States should
put in place the necessary mechanisms for monitoring compliance with
the established standards and ensuring that illegal disposal of waste by
companies is penalized.
32. As with Article 21, Article 24 is predicated on and significantly constituted
by the right of people to timely and accessible information. People have
the right to be provided with and to share information regarding all
industrial activities or projected natural events that may cause damage to
the environment and thereby threatening the life, health and livelihood of
people. People should be consulted about all the activities or conditions that
may affect the soil, water, fauna and flora and air of the territory in which
they reside and their views should be duly taken into account in all decisionmaking relating to their environment and development activities in the
areas of their residence. Consultations have to be adequate and inclusive.
There should be legal and institutional avenues that afford people the
opportunity both for receiving information and being heard. People should
be able to make oral or written submissions individually or collectively and
directly by themselves or through the support of autonomous community
organizations including civil society groups.
33. In case of despoliation of the environment resulting from the activities of
extractive industries, people residing in the affected areas are entitled to a
number of protection measures. As the African Commission pointed out in
the SERAC case, such despoliation also entails that scientific inspection/
assessment of the nature and scale of environmental, health and socioeconomic impact of oil spillage, gas flare ups, leakage of dangerous
chemicals into land, water and air is promptly conducted. Affected
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
29
communities should be provided with all information on the nature of the
despoliation, on its actual and potential environmental and health impacts
and on measures to be taken.
34. People are also entitled to full, adequate and effective compensation for the
consequences of environmental damage arising from industrial activities.
Specifically, they should be compensated for material loss, livelihood
disruptions including opportunity costs and illness as well as emotional
distress resulting from such environmental damage. Where environmental
damage causes irreparable harm to the health of affected people, they
should have access to affordable health care and sustainable support and
assistance for as long as their conditions require it. They should also be
provided with support for the rehabilitation of their livelihoods.
35. Similarly, in such cases of environmental despoliation or pollution from
industrial activities, people are entitled to the measures necessary for the
cleaning up and restoration of the affected environment. Despoliation of
the environment may continue after mine closure or when the extractive
processes have come to an end. The protective measures for affected
persons continue to apply equally in such cases.
36. Under Article 24, people are also entitled to the right to justice. They should
therefore have access to appropriate judicial and non-judicial mechanisms
for raising their grievances and seeking appropriate remedy, similar to that
discussed under paragraph 24 above.
III
Obligations of States
37. Under the African Charter, States Parties to the Charter bear both general
obligations and specific duties with respect to the rights set out in the African
Charter. As stipulated in Article 1 of the Charter, the general obligation
requires States Parties to “recognise” the rights, duties and freedoms
enshrined in the Charter, and “to adopt legislative or other measures to
give effect to them.” These obligations apply to Articles 21 and 24 of the
African Charter as well. States are accordingly duty bound to give legal
application to these rights. To this end, State Parties should incorporate the
rights in these Articles into their national law. This is the first part of the
general obligation of states.
30
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
38. Apart from incorporating the rights into national legislation, legislative
measures further include laying down effective and adequately resourced
mechanisms and institutions to supervise and enforce the necessary fiscal,
environmental, labor and human rights protection standards that give effect
to these rights. The “other measures” that States should take under Article
1 to give effect to these rights additionally include provision of relevant
administrative and judicial mechanisms for seeking remedies in cases of
violations. States are required to adopt national policies, strategies and
plans geared towards the realization of all the rights. These should be
accompanied by budgetary measures. These are the measures that make
available the required resources for the implementation of the legislative
and policy measures.
39. Complementing the obligations under Article 1, States are also regarded
as having the general obligation of advocating for the rights guaranteed.
This is stipulated under Article 25 of the African Charter. In this context,
the measures of relevance for purposes of Articles 21 and 24 are advocacy
works involving educational and awareness-raising activities, for example
through the incorporation of specific topics into the curriculum of law
studies, development studies, and international relations/political science
studies at tertiary level. In this regard, States should enable advocacy for
rights and that there should be protective measures in place for human rights
defenders and members of affected communities to exercise and advocate
for their rights, without fear of harassment, restriction, or barriers to justice.
40. In the SERAC case, the African Commission identified the specific
obligations arising from the provisions guaranteeing the rights in the Charter
as entailing duties of respect, protection, promotion and fulfillment. The
duty to respect imposes negative obligations on the State to refrain from
interfering in or causing interference in the rights guaranteed under Articles
21 and 24. This means that State agents or anyone acting on behalf of
the State or exercising public authority should avoid actions restricting or
curtailing the rights in these articles. In essence, these actors should exercise
care in the discharge of their responsibilities or in undertaking their activities
to avoid causing harm.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
31
41. The legislative measures for the realization of the duty to respect should
include internationally acceptable expropriation rules with the necessary
safeguards to protect individuals and local people from arbitrary State
actions or decisions that may lead to arbitrary land dispossession or
deprivation, which should include the prohibition of expropriation for uses
other than a public purpose. In addition, legislative measures should provide
for the process to be applied and the standards to be followed in cases of
expropriation or resettlement including consultation with affected members
of society, provision of due notice, the payment of adequate compensation
and support for rehabilitation. Furthermore, it should ensure that the
standards, which apply to compensation to be paid by local companies,
should not in any way be to the detriment of the affected people.
42. Derived from the right of peoples to live on, access, develop and use the
land, vegetation, water sources and the aquatic resources on which they
depend for their survival and livelihoods, there is a corresponding duty on
the State to ensure that there is a legal framework in place which ensures
protection of land and resource ownership rights by the people, even if
they do not have formal title over the land or in the case of collective
ownership. In this regard it is necessary to also take account of the often
more precarious nature of land ownership by women in Africa.
43. Also in relation to the duty to respect is the obligation on States to respect
the ability of other African States to deliver the same to their people, as
derived from the obligation of States to collectively exercise the right to free
disposal of wealth and natural resources.
44. With respect to the right to a general satisfactory environment, the duty
to respect entails that the State should not interfere unnecessarily with
the enjoyment by people of this right. In this context again, the issue of
consultation and participation of the affected persons is crucial. In addition,
the State should have due regard to the cultural and natural heritage and
sacred sites of peoples and communities.21
45. The second is the duty to protect. In the context of Articles 21 and 24
of the African Charter, the obligations of the State include putting in
place internationally acceptable standards on environmental protection, on
financial responsibilities in relation to the development of natural resources,
32
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
and on guarantees against abuse of human rights and labour standards
throughout the operation cycle of the extractive industries. Such legislation
and policies should mandate the establishment or legal empowerment of
existing institutions to monitor and ensure compliance with fiscal or other
transparency initiatives, and provide them with the necessary authority and
resources to enforce compliance. Such legislation on applicable standards
should further ensure the application of human rights and relevant safety
and environmental standards for protecting individuals and communities
involved in and dependent on artisanal mining with particular attention to
the rights of children, women, indigenous populations/communities, people
with disabilities, migrant workers and other vulnerable groups. Measures
should be put in place to combat corruption linked to Government entities
in charge of ensuring the implementation of the relevant laws. States should
adopt legislation and put in place measures particularly on restriction of
extraction in conflict-affected areas and criminal liability for involvement of
companies in human rights abuses in conflict situations.
46. In terms of Article 21 of the African Charter, the duty to protect entails that
the State adopts comprehensive and beneficial fiscal legislation covering the
revenue regime by which extractive industries are bound including license
fees, profits taxes, royalties, dividends, bonuses, customs duties and capital
gains tax.22 Such legislation should impose legal obligations on companies
in extractive industries to declare profits derived from their operations and
reporting obligations on compliance with all applicable tax obligations, and
in this regard should provide for the way in which as well as the frequency
with which such declarations should be made. Such legislation should also
provide for rules and inspection/investigation avenues that ensure strict
application of tax breaks and duty free privileges and address the exploitation
of any lacuna that exist in the monetary regulatory regimes including
the tax breaks and duty free privileges. Apart from tax and incentives
regimes, such legislation regulating the fiscal framework should also take
account of fiscal transparency of the whole processes of management
of extractive concessions, for instance in cases of joint-ventures. In
addition, States should develop and implement robust and efficient tax
collection systems in order to address the challenge of illicit financial flow.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
33
47. States should further adopt the required institutional measures for monitoring
and enforcing the fiscal, environmental, labour, health and human rights
observance standards by third parties including business establishments
particularly in the extractive industries and joint-ventures where the State
is a partner in the economic activity. In this regard the State should create
conditions for the effective role of National Human Rights Institutions in
promoting and protecting human rights at the national level. States should
lay down the administrative, civil and criminal liabilities that result from the
failure of non-state actors including businesses such as those in extractive
industries to comply with these standards and any harm or violations arising
from such non-compliance. In this regard, States should not limit company
liability for environmental clean-up costs or continuing violations once the
extractive activities come to an end or pending claims at the time when
ownership is transferred. States thus bear the obligation to investigate and,
as necessary, apply the legally established penalties in compliance with duly
established procedures. In case of breaches of applicable standards, States
have obligation to ensure that those operating in the extractive industries
are held to a high standard of civil and criminal liability both for their own
actions and for the actions of those acting on their behalf or to their benefit.
48. The duty to protect encompasses the laying down of the standards on the
process and criteria for the granting of concession or licenses to extractive
companies for exploration and extraction of natural resources. This in
particular means that licences to extractive industries should be negotiated
and granted in accordance with internationally accepted rules and standards,
based on transparency and human and peoples’ rights. Such standards not
only create opportunities for public participation but also ensure that the
general public and local people are protected from licensing terms that are
exploitative and limit the liability of extractive industries.
49. An important element of the duty to protect is also the provision of
effective, well-resourced and technically equipped judicial and non-judicial
mechanisms for receiving complaints and adjudicating disputes. These
mechanisms should have the requisite jurisdiction to adjudicate cases
including those arising from alleged non-compliance with relevant standards
and from disputes involving extractive industries and local people. The
relevant legislative act establishing such judicial mechanisms should allow
citizens to sue companies. The right of citizens to challenge the actions or
34
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
the impacts of the activities of extractive industries should not be restricted
in any way, including through statutes of limitations in accessing the courts.
50. Under Article 24 of the African Charter, in case of a threatened environment,
the duty to protect entails that proper scientific monitoring and relevant
corrective measures are undertaken by the State. Similarly, in cases of
despoliation or pollution of the environment, the relevant legislative and
regulatory rules should lay down the standards and processes to be applied
for a) assessing the despoliation or pollution, b) the clean-up and restoration
of the affected environment, and c) the compensation of the affected
persons/peoples.
51. The third duty is the duty to promote the rights. As the African Commission
puts it, this entails that the State should make sure that individuals are able
to exercise their rights and freedoms. This they should do, for example, by
promoting tolerance, raising awareness, and even building infrastructures.
In the context of Articles 21 and 24, the duty to promote involves enacting
the relevant implementing legislation and elaborating policies and action
plans for enabling the general public and particularly potentially affected
local people to have advance and continuous access to all the relevant
information on natural resources and the environment. It also entails
that the relevant regulatory bodies are equipped with and duly mandated
to disseminate such information, and undertake awareness creation and
public education activities. In the current reality of limited resources and
institutional capacity, one way of realizing the duty to promote is to create
the conducive legal conditions that would enable members of society, local
communities and civil society actors to organize and engage in promotional
activities particularly those relating to public education and awareness
creation as well as effective participation in decision-making processes.
52. In addition to and related to information is the provision of guarantees for
undertaking consultations with and ensuring the participation of the wider
public in general and local people in particular, including vulnerable groups
and children. As part of the duty to promote, States are accordingly required
to ensure that the public is availed adequate opportunities for consultation
about and rich and rigorous participation in decision-making processes on
plans for both industrial exploration and extraction of natural resources and
other large-scale activities with potential environmental and social impacts.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
35
All concerns raised by affected people should be fully incorporated into the
final decision. Such consultations and participation should start prior to
(and should continue during) the implementation of such projects.
53. The fourth and final duty is the duty to fulfil. This requires in the context
of Articles 21 and 24 that steps are taken to create the necessary conditions
that make it possible for people to benefit from these rights. These are
the steps that enable the right holders to develop, have access to and use
natural resources, including provision for avenues that enable members of
the public and local people to have shares in extractive industries. With
specific reference to Article 21 and in relation to the operations of extractive
industries, these steps include the collection and judicious investment of the
revenues and proceeds from the exploitation of natural resources.
54. These in particular may include investment in the establishment of the
necessary social services and physical infrastructure and provision of
support for the improvement of the sources of livelihood of local people
particularly in the areas of operation of extractive industries, as well as
investment in benefits to future generations. This would further include the
duty to ensure that where irreparable harm has been done to the health of a
person due to damage that the operation of extractive industries cause to the
environment that such person is provided with the necessary health service
and other support. The application of the duty to fulfil should be applied
with due regard to the need to prioritize the interests of vulnerable sections
of society. For example, legislation should provide for the regulation of the
artisanal/small scale mining sector, in order to increase their access to loans
tailored to their capacity and conditions and other financial assistance from
financial agencies as well as the necessary technical support that improve
their safety and enhance their capacity and development.
55. With respect to Article 24, the duty to fulfil entails that States make the
necessary investments for the conservation and improvement of the
environment. Where the environment is endangered as a result of natural
developments, this also entails that States, within their available means,
should initiate works for the rehabilitation of the endangered environment
including through collaboration with local and international actors that have
the technical capacity for such works.
36
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
IV
Obligations of companies
56. While States are the primary obligation bearers under the African Charter,
it is also legally recognized that corporations, particularly multinational
ones, have obligations towards right holders.23 This obligation arises from
the recognition that lack of such obligations may result in the creation of
a human rights vacuum in which such entities operate without observing
human rights. Under the African Charter, obligations of such entities
towards rights holders have a clear legislative basis. Article 27 of the African
Charter provides for the duties of individuals and its sub-provision 2 lays
down the obligation to exercise rights ‘with due regard to the rights of
others’. Clearly, if this obligation can be imposed on individuals, there is
an even stronger moral and legal basis for attributing these obligations to
corporations and companies.
57. The first of these obligations is a direct negative obligation based on the
principle of do no harm or in its positive formulation the principle of due
care. This entails that companies and corporations should ensure that their
actions or operations do not result in or trigger the occurrence of harm or
the curtailment or deprivation of the rights guaranteed under the African
Charter.24 They should not only refrain from deliberate acts that constitute
or result in such violations but also ensure continuously that their acts or
operations are in full compliance with internationally accepted human and
peoples’ rights, labour and environmental standards to avoid any incident
producing harm or curtailment of rights of people, including in conflict
situations.25
58. In applying the duties in the African Charter to companies, and on account
of the huge extent of power that companies, particularly multinational
ones, exercise in comparison to individual persons, they have a resultant and
corresponding higher level of duty of both due diligence and care.26 They
should be vigilant in having a clear understanding of the nature and impact
of their activities, take the required measures for preventing their activities
from having adverse human rights impacts and put in place mechanisms
for rectifying any negative human rights impacts arising from their activities
or actions. In this regard they should also ensure responsible supply chain
management to ensure that their actions and decisions do not have negative
repercussions further down the supply chain. In order to ascertain the extent
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
37
of the impact of their activities, companies should do, with the participation
of local communities, human rights impact assessments and ensure that
these assessments are appropriately consultative and take account of the
rights of vulnerable persons and groups.
59. Where breaches occur on account of the activities or actions of companies,
various administrative, civil and criminal responsibilities ensue. Where
activities of extractive industries result in despoliation of the environment,
they bear responsibility for paying due compensation to affected people
for all material and non-material damages suffered, including compensation
in the case of irreparable harm to health, and for the cleaning and
rehabilitation of the affected environment.27 In administrative terms, they
will be responsible for any fines or administrative measures laid down in law
or in the licensing agreement.
60. In terms of criminal liability, the kind of acts for which companies may
be held responsible are, for example, laid down under the AU Protocol
on Amendments to the Protocol on the Statute of the African Court of
Justice and Human Rights, adopted during the June 2014 AU summit held
in Malabo, Equatorial Guinea (the Malabo Protocol).28 These acts include:
a) Concluding an agreement to exploit resources, in violation of the
principle of peoples’ sovereignty over their natural resources;
b) Concluding with State authorities an agreement to exploit natural
resources in violation of the legal and regulatory procedures of the
State concerned;
c) Concluding an agreement to exploit natural resources through corrupt
practices;
d) Concluding an agreement to exploit natural resources that is clearly
one-sided;
e) Exploiting natural resources without any agreement with the state
concerned;
f) Exploiting natural resources without complying with norms relating to
the protection of the environment and the security of the people and
the staff; and
g) Violating the norms and standards established by the relevant natural
resource certification mechanism.
38
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
61. ‘Security of people and the staff ’ as provided for under (f) above, should be
understood in the broad sense and include both physical safety and security
as well as financial security.
62. Companies also bear indirect negative obligations. They thus bear
responsibility for the activities or actions of those that act on their behalf
or to their benefit including the private security companies they use for
securing their facilities and personnel. Accordingly, they should ensure that
such activities or actions undertaken on their behalf or to their benefit do
not cause harm or result in interference in the enjoyment of protected rights.
Where such activities or actions result in curtailment or interference with
the rights protected in the African Charter, the company on whose behalf
or to whose benefit those activities or actions have been taken should bear
administrative, civil and/or criminal responsibility as applicable.
63. In addition to the negative obligations, in certain circumstance companies
also bear certain positive obligations arising from the human and peoples’
rights of the Charter in general and Articles 21 and 24 in particular. The first
set of obligations in this regard relate to the various fiscal and transparency
requirements arising from the operations of their activities.29 These include
all applicable fiscal responsibilities and transparency obligations including
disclosure of identities of owners, shareholders and local partners; fully
declaring profits they make from their operations in the host country;
disclosing financial terms of agreements relating to license fees, national
and local taxes, custom duties, royalties and shares due to the government
in terms of the contract and applicable laws of the country; and adopting
measures to comply with requirements against illicit financial flow.
64. The second set of positive obligations is that arising from the social and
economic impacts of the operations of extractive industries or other
companies on the host community including on the land and natural
resources rights of affected people.30 In conducting their operations, these
business entities should adequately inform and substantively consult with
the affected people on any of their activities or on decisions that may
materially affect the people and implement such activities having regard
to the concerns of the people and the requisite cautionary measures for
mitigating such impacts.31 In this regard, companies should also do,
with the participation and representation of affected local communities,
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
39
the requisite environmental, social and human rights impact assessments
before undertaking any actions, which may have negative implications for
the affected people.
65. Also arising from the social and economic impacts of the operations of
companies and the nature of the power that they exercise are obligations of
companies to contribute to the development needs of the host communities.32
These obligations are legal obligations rather than just matters of social
responsibility of companies.33 These obligations in particular include
supporting community-based employment and economic diversification to
reduce reliance on the extractive industries as the sole source of income,
educational, health, agricultural or pastoral development projects, as well
as providing access to mine facilities and infrastructure. It also entails an
obligation, once the extractive operations have come to an end, to support
the transition of affected people to reliance on alternative livelihoods.
•••
40
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
Endnotes
1
See the Resolution of the African Commission on the Niamey Declaration on
Ensuring the Upholding of the African Charter in the Extractive Industries Sector, ACHPR/
Res. 367 (LX) 2017, available at http://www.achpr.org/sessions/60th/resolutions/367/.
2
Examples include the conflicts in the eastern region of the Democratic Republic
of the Congo; western Sudan as well as in the Niger Delta in Nigeria.
3
T Hentschel et al (2002); Global Report on Artisanal & Small-Scale Mining 4.
4
See Communication 155/96 – Social and Economic Rights Action Center (SERAC) and Center for Economic and Social Rights (CESR) v. Nigeria (2001) (the SERAC
case).
5
Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative ‘EITI Glossary’, available at
https://eiti.org/glossary; Cambridge dictionary definition of ‘extractive industry’ available
at https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/extractive-industry.
6
Financial Times ‘Financial Times Lexicon’ available at http://lexicon.ft.com/
Term?term=extractive-industry.
7
See Report of the Panel of Experts on the Illegal Exploitation of Natural Resources and Other Forms of Wealth of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
8
Communication 75/92 - Katangese Peoples’ Congress v. Zaire.
9
Communication 75/92 - Katangese Peoples’ Congress v. Zaire; Communication
211/98 – Legal Resources Centre v Zambia; Communication 279/03-296/05 – Sudan
Human Rights Organization and Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions (COHRE) v.
Sudan; Communication 276/03 – Centre for Minority Rights Development (Kenya) and
Minority Rights Group International (on behalf of Endorois Welfare Council) v. the Republic of Kenya (the Endorois case).
10
See ACHPR, Principles and Guidelines on the implementation of Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights in the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights.
11
Definition similar in content to the definition provided for ‘natural resources’ in
Article V(1) of the African Convention on the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (Revised edition) 2003. This definition is also in line with the exposition of natural
resources as provided for in paras 123, 124 and 254 of the Endorois decision.
12
See Para. 6 of the Preamble to the African Charter ‘recognizing on the one hand
that human rights stem from the attributes of human beings […] and on the other hand,
that the reality and respect of peoples’ rights should necessarily guarantee human rights’.
13
Also see the UN Draft Principles on Human Rights and the Environment (produced as attachment to the 1994 Report of the UN Special Rapporteur).
14
The rights and duties of persons are provided for in Articles 1 to 29 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
41
15
See Resolution ACHPR/Res.224 (LI) 2012 on a human rights-based approach to the
governance of natural resources.
16
See the SERAC case.
17
See para 7 of the Preamble to the African Charter and Chapter II of the African
Charter on duties.
18
AfCHPR, Application No. 006/12, The African Commission on Human and
Peoples’ Rights v. The Republic of Kenya, paras. 200-201.
19
See the Endorois case.
20
Existing State Reporting Guidelines on Article 21 and best practices.
21
See for example ACHPR/Res. 372 (LX) 2017 Resolution on the Protection of
Sacred Natural Sites and Territories.
22
Existing State Reporting Guidelines.
23
Speech delivered during the inaugural General Assembly of African Coalition for Corporate Responsibility - Commissioner Solomon Ayele Dersso, Chairperson
of the Working Group on Extractive Industries, available at http://www.achpr.org/
news/2016/07/d226/.
24
The duty to respect and consider others and maintain relations aimed at promoting, safeguarding and reinforcing mutual respect and tolerance is provided for in Article 28
of the African Charter. The United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human
Rights (the Ruggie Principles) confirm in Principle 11 that businesses ‘should avoid infringing on the human rights of others and should address adverse human rights impacts with
which they are involved’. See also ACHPR/Res. 367 (LX) 2017 Resolution on the Niamey
Declaration on Ensuring the Upholding of the African Charter in the Extractive Industries
Sector.
25
Articles 27(1) and (2) and 28 of the African Charter.
26
Flows from the logic of applying the duties in the African Charter to legal persons.
27
See note i above.
28
While the Malabo Protocol has not yet entered into force, it is one example of
the growing consensus between African States on the kinds of acts for which companies
may be held criminally liable. The International Criminal Court in A Policy Paper on Case
Selection and Prioritisation adopted in September 2016 also announced that ‘[t]he Office
will also seek to cooperate and provide assistance to States, upon request, with respect to
conduct which constitutes a serious crime under national law, such as the illegal exploitation of natural resources, arms trafficking, human trafficking, terrorism, financial crimes,
and grabbing or the destruction of the environment’
29
In the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, these are formulated as voluntary obligations of transparency.
42
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
30
Article 27 of the African Charter; see also ACHPR/Res. 367 (LX) 2017 Resolution on the Niamey Declaration on Ensuring the Upholding of the African Charter in the
Extractive Industries Sector.
31
Article 9 of the African Charter; Ruggie Principles, Principle 11; ACHPR/Res.
367 (LX) 2017.
32
See Article 27; This is also demonstrated through best practice in South Africa,
where the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002 provides in
terms of sections 23 (h), 24 (3), 25 (2), 28 (2) and 85 (3) amongst others, that a mining
company has to submit a social and labour plan when applying for mining rights. Social and
labour plans are regarded as forming part of corporate social responsibility.
33
In the context of the African Charter, which imposes duties on all persons, and
given the resources at the disposal of extractive industries, as well as the extent and nature
of the communities who are reliant on the extractive industries sector, the provisions of
the African Charter, particularly Article 27 to 29 should be read to also impose duties on
companies.
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
43
Annexes
Resolution 364: Resolution on Developing Reporting Guidelines
with Respect to the Extractive Industries
ACHPR/Res. 364(LIX) 2016
The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the Commission), meeting at
its 59th Ordinary Session held from 21 October to 4 November 2016 in Banjul, Islamic
Republic of The Gambia;
Recalling its mandate to promote and protect human and peoples’ rights in
Africa under the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights (the African
Charter);
Recalling its Resolution ACHPR/Res.148 (XLV1) 09, establishing the Working
Group on Extractive Industries, Environment and Human Rights Violations in
Africa (the Working Group), adopted during the 46th Ordinary Session held in
Banjul, The Gambia from 11 to 25 November 2009;
Further recalling Resolution ACHPR/Res.321(LVII)2015 appointing Commissioner Solomon Dersso as the new Chairperson of the Working Group and the
extension of the term of its members, adopted at the 57th Ordinary Session of
the Commission held from 4 to 18 November 2015 in Banjul, Islamic Republic
of The Gambia;
Recognising the importance of the Working Group in contributing to the work
of the Commission towards an improved protection of human rights and the
environment within the context of extractive industries;
Further recognising that the lack of reporting guidelines on extractive industries
undermines the monitoring of compliance by State Parties with Charter standards;
The Commission:
Decides to mandate the Working Group to elaborate reporting guidelines that
adequately guide State Parties on the information they should incorporate in
their periodic report.
Done in Banjul, Islamic Republic of The Gambia, on 4 November 2016
44
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
Resolution 367: Resolution on the Niamey Declaration on
Ensuring the Upholding of the African Charter
in the Extractive Industries Sector
ACHPR/Res. 367 (LX) 2017
The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, meeting at its 60th Ordinary
Session held from 8 to 22 May 2017 in Niamey, Republic of Niger;
Recalling its mandate to promote and ensure the protection of human and
peoples’ rights in Africa under the African Charter on Human and Peoples’
Rights (African Charter);
Recalling its Resolution ACHPR/Res.148 (XLV1) 09 establishing the Working
Group on Extractive Industries, Environment and Human Rights Violations
in Africa (Working Group) adopted during the 46th Ordinary Session held in
Banjul, The Gambia, from 11 to 25 November 2009; Resolution ACHPR/
Res.224 (LI) 2012 on a human rights-based approach to natural resources
governance adopted during the 51st Ordinary Session held from 18 April to
2 May 2012 in Banjul, The Gambia; Resolution ACHPR/Res.236 (LIII) 2013
on illicit flight of capital from Africa adopted during the 53rd Ordinary Session
held from 9 to 23 April 2013;
Underscoring that the right to freely dispose of wealth and natural resources is
an inviolable right of all peoples guaranteed under Article 21 of the African
Charter;
Acknowledging that in many African countries extractive industries constitute a
source of revenue representing a substantial part of foreign direct investment
which, if managed in a viable, sustainable and transparent manner respectful
of charter-based rights, can contribute to broad-based and inclusive socioeconomic development;
Reiterating the primary responsibility of States Parties to prevent and provide
redress in accordance with the African Charter for all forms of violations of
human and peoples’ rights, including violations involving non-state actors;
Affirming that extractive industries have the legal obligation to respect the
rights guaranteed in the African Charter;
Concerned by the lack of transparency prevailing in relation to the negotiation
and terms of concessionary contracts and the receipt and use of revenues;
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
45
Alarmed by the low respect of human and peoples’ rights in the extractive
industries sector resulting in extensive individual and collective human rights
violations;
Concerned by the exploitative terms on the basis of which the extractive
industries operate in many parts of the continent depriving the populations of
the benefits to which it is entitled and often causing adverse environmental and
social impacts further exacerbating poverty in the host communities;
Noting with deep concern the loss of a considerable amount of revenues due to weak
governance and tax regimes as well as bargaining capacity resulting in unduly
long tax holidays, disadvantageous duty-free privileges and the exploitation by
extractive companies and individuals of the loopholes in such legal regimes and
licensing contracts;
Further concerned by the increasing destruction with impunity of the environment
and ecosystems resulting from poorly regulated activities of the extractive
industries in Africa;
Convinced of the need for transforming the national legal and regulatory
framework of the activities of the extractive industries, in line with the
African Charter, to the development needs of society and the benefit of
local communities, indigenous populations/communities, women, children,
mine workers and other vulnerable groups living in the areas of operation of
extractive industries;
The Commission:
1. Requests States Parties to ensure that relevant legislation is adopted or existing
ones reviewed in order to:
a.
Stipulate provisions for sharing revenues from operations of extractive
industries between national government, regional authorities and
local communities;
b. Require that licences to extractive industries are negotiated and
granted in accordance with internationally accepted rules and
standards, based on transparency and human and peoples’ rights;
c.
Guarantee that all the financial terms of agreements with extractive
companies including those relating to licence fees, national and local
taxes, custom duties, royalties and shares due to the State are not
exploitative;
46
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
d.
e.
f.
g.
h.
i.
j.
Require that communities and individuals residing in areas earmarked
for prospection and development of natural resources are properly
consulted, provided with all information relating to exploration and
development activities from the very inception and are assured that
exploration and development activities are undertaken with due
respect to the agreed terms protecting their rights;
Ensure that concessionary contracts are negotiated with active
participation of representatives of affected communities and
community-based organizations and that their terms are made known
to the public in accordance with the requirements of transparency
and respect for all the human and peoples’ rights in the African
Charter;
Require that all revenues received by the State from the activities
of extractive companies and the use to which they have been put
are independently audited, made known to the public in the local
languages and subject to parliamentary scrutiny;
Put in place regulatory bodies vested with the relevant powers for
ensuring that human rights, environmental and labour standards are
duly respected and environmental and social impacts are mitigated;
Impose criminal and administrative accountability for all those
involved in corrupt practices and misappropriation of public funds
accruing from the operations of the extractive industries;
Provide non-judicial and judicial grievance mechanisms accessible
to affected communities and adequately equipped and resourced for
handling cases involving extractive industries; and
Ensure the application of human rights and relevant safety and
environmental standards for protecting individuals and communities
involved in and dependent on artisanal mining with particular
attention to the rights of children, women, indigenous populations/
communities and other vulnerable groups.
2. Calls on States Parties to institute laws where these do not exist, or reform
existing laws to recognize and enshrine the obligations of extractive
industries to respect the rights in the African Charter throughout their
operation cycle, including for:
a. Implementing exploration and development activities with due
respect to the terms agreed in consultations guaranteeing the rights
and interests of host communities;
State Reporting Guidelines and Principles |
47
b.
c.
d.
e.
Paying due compensation to affected communities for all material and
non-material damages suffered and for the cleaning and rehabilitation
of affected environment in cases of despoliation of the environment;
Bearing civil and criminal responsibility and paying compensation for
human and peoples’ rights violations and/or abuses arising from their
extractive industrial activities or from activities of those operating on
their behalf or for assisting or abating such violations by state or nonstate actors including private security companies;
Contributing to the development needs of the communities in the
areas of their operations including through supporting communitybased employment, educational, health, agricultural or pastoral
development projects; and
Disclosing the identity of shareholders and local partners, fully
declaring profits they make from their operations in the host country
and for publicizing all payments that they make to government in
terms of the contract and applicable laws of the country.
3. Urges States Parties to adopt laws and regulations aimed at easing the
transition of affected communities from economic dependence on
extractive industries to reliance on other livelihoods when activities of
extractive industries are closed down, in line with regional and international
human rights laws and principles;
4. Calls on States Parties to enforce such requirements where sufficient
legislation currently exists including the provision of grievance mechanisms
for all cases of violations of rights guaranteed in the African Charter;
5. Urges States Parties to establish regional mechanisms for:
a. Cooperation and the exchange of good practices between States
Parties to strengthen capacities and develop the necessary institutional
and legal framework to ensure that mining contracts are negotiated
to the benefit of and in consultation with affected individuals, local
communities and indigenous populations/communities;
b. Developing capacities for value addition and beneficiation;
c. Building regional marketing platforms for assessing the commercial
value of the resources exported from their territories; and
d. Fighting illicit financial flights common in the extractive industries.
Done in Niamey, Republic of Niger, on 22 May 2017
48
| African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights